Prepared for C-Level
For Scott Blackledge and Johnny-Lee Reinoso
What we heard from you, the packages side by side, and how the first 90 days would go.
The packagesHow we'd startService levelsThe agreement
By Caleb Sherrill and Lui Prieto, SMBHR, November 17, 2026.
What we heard from you.
Five things came up on our call. Each one is covered in what follows.
- 01
HR and payroll need a dedicated owner
- Payroll, benefits, insurance and state registrations have sat in one set of hands
- Your team needs to know payroll will run on time, every time
- You and Johnny-Lee want it off your plates
- 02
Four states, one of them Illinois
- People in Florida, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Illinois
- Illinois carries more leave, notice and pay rules than most states
- State tax and unemployment accounts sit with your PEO
- 03
Pay that moves every period
- Salaries plus per-meeting pay and spiffs
- The rules and exceptions live in your CRM
- We need them a few days before each payroll
- 04
On Paychex PEO today
- Payroll, dental, vision, life, 401(k) and workers' comp run through Paychex
- We still need to see the medical plan and what it costs
- You keep Paychex, and we run payroll in it for you
- 05
Service levels in writing, little time from you
- Response times and deadlines spelled out
- No charge for every call, text or email
- One approval from you per payroll
Core, Partner and Strategic, line by line.
Priced for C-Level today: 1 to 10 total workers in Florida, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Illinois, on a PEO, with payroll run by us. Every price includes your states and payroll. Anything not included is a printed price, agreed before the work starts.
| What's included | Core$2,650a monthFor when someone inside runs HR day to day and needs a backstop | RecommendedPartner$3,550a monthWe run HR alongside Scott and Johnny-Lee, with the usual people issues included | Strategic$5,350a monthDirector-led, with pay structure, org planning and a standing leadership cadence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every month | |||
| A named HR lead who knows C-LevelWho leads your account at each tier | Generalist-led, coordinator-supported | Generalist-led, director oversight | Director-led |
| Employee question lineScott and Johnny-Lee, managers and employees ask us directly, including advice on performance issues and write-ups | Everyone, employees included | Everyone, employees included | Everyone, employees included |
| Monthly compliance reportOne page: census check, threshold watch, calendar items done and due | Included | Included | Included |
| Rolling 12-month compliance calendarFor Florida, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Illinois | Included | Included | Included |
| Monthly census pullAlso how new states, entities and band crossings get caught | Included | Included | Included |
| Payroll oversight, files and I-9 tracking, policy watchWe check the Paychex runs and flag law changes that touch your policies | Included | Included | Included |
| Vendor liaisonWe deal with Paychex, your benefits broker and your other HR vendors | Included | Included | Included |
| Quarterly scorecard re-runThe 20-question score, so progress is a number | Included | Included | Included |
| Check-ins with leadershipTwo check-ins in the first month, then: | Monthly | Monthly, plus a quarterly strategy session | Quarterly business review, plus a standing leadership cadence |
| Pay structure and org planningBuilt with leadership, then kept current | A priced project | A priced project | Included |
| We run your payrollWe stage each run for your named approver; your provider still moves the money and files the taxes | In the price above | In the price above | In the price above |
| When people issues come up | |||
| Termination supportSeparation documents and the plan, or we join the conversation | $1,250 each | 2 a quarter includedthen $1,250 each | 4 a quarter includedthen $1,250 each |
| Performance improvement plansWe draft the plan and coach the manager through it | $1,250 each | 1 a quarter includedthen $1,250 each | 2 a quarter includedthen $1,250 each |
| Unemployment claimsResponses drafted for you | $450 each | 2 a quarter includedthen $450 each | 4 a quarter includedthen $450 each |
| Leave casesFMLA, ADA and state leave, run end to end | $1,100 each | Included at normal volume | Included at normal volume |
| Accommodation requestsThe interactive process, documentation and decision memo | $1,200 each | 1 a quarter includedthen $1,200 each | 2 a quarter includedthen $1,200 each |
| Hires and exits | |||
| Onboarding a new hireOffer packet, I-9, file setup, first-day checklist | $750 each | 4 a quarter includedthen $750 each | 8 a quarter includedthen $750 each |
| Offboarding an exitExit checklist, final-pay rules, COBRA notice coordination | $750 each | 2 a quarter includedthen $750 each | 4 a quarter includedthen $750 each |
| Bigger matters, at every tier | |||
| Workplace investigationTriage is included; the investigation itself is a fixed fee per matter | From $6,000 | From $6,000 | From $6,000 |
| Agency letter or charge responseDOL, EEOC or a state agency, with employment counsel | $2,500 per matter | $2,500 per matter | $2,500 per matter |
| Setup work | |||
| Baseline HR auditThe 14-area review that starts every engagement. $2,500 on its own | Free with a 12-month agreement | Free with a 12-month agreement | Free with a 12-month agreement |
| Response time | |||
| Standard questions answered withinEmergencies are handled the same business day at every tier | 48 business hours | 24 business hours | 24 business hours |
Not in any package, priced before we start
- One-time projects such as pay structure and org planning or a new handbook, at a fixed price in writing.
- A day on site, $1,000 plus travel, per full day.
- Recruiting. We help you choose a recruiting firm and onboard the hire.
- Legal advice. We tell you when something needs a lawyer and hand them a clean file.
Why we recommend Partner for C-Level: once the handoff is done, nobody inside will own HR day to day, and four states including Illinois bring rules a small team rarely sees. Partner gives you director oversight and a quarterly strategy session, and covers the open unemployment claim and the hires and exits a team your size brings, included up to the printed counts.
The first 90 days.
Your fixed monthly fee goes in writing first. Dates assume a Monday, Nov 23 start.
- Week 1Nov 23 to 27
Kickoff
Kickoff call, our Paychex logins, your first payroll.
- Weeks 2 to 4Nov 30 to Dec 18
The HR audit
14 areas, across all four states.
- Day 30Dec 22
Findings
What we found, ranked by risk.
- Months 2 and 3Dec 23 to Feb 18
Fix by risk
Starting with the unemployment claim.
- Day 90Feb 19
Package confirmed
Checked against real volume.
What we promise, and how you check it.
The short version. The full wording is in the agreement.
What we promise
- Lui leads your account, Caleb backs her up
- Answers within 24 business hours, urgent the same day
- Payroll preview 3 business days before payday
- Your approval by noon, 2 business days before payday
- Your CRM numbers to us 4 business days before payday
- Check-ins: two in month one, then monthly
- No meter on calls, texts or emails
How you check our work
- We never hold your money or your bank logins
- Two people on every payroll: we prepare, you approve
- Pay changes in writing first, kept on file
- Direct deposit changes flagged before payroll runs
- Our own named Paychex logins. You stay the admin
- Quarterly roster check: you confirm who is on payroll
Day to day, all in the monthly fee
No extra charge and no meter for any of this.
- Running payroll every two weeks
- Per-meeting pay and spiffs added to payroll
- Employee questions on pay, PTO and benefits
- Advice on performance issues and write-ups
- PTO balances kept right
- Direct deposit, W-4 and address changes
- Benefits questions and life-event changes, with your broker
- Open enrollment, coordinated with your broker
- Paychex tickets, errors and notices
- State tax and unemployment letters
- Employment and income verifications
- Required notices and filing deadlines
- Employee files and I-9s kept in order
- Law changes in your four states flagged
- W-2s and year-end payroll checked
- A one-page compliance report every month
Senior HR people who know C-Level by name.
Quality and expertise are the reason to bring in an HR team. Here is who C-Level gets from us.
Over a decade in HR
Lui Prieto, our Co-Founder and Chief People Strategist, leads C-Level's account.
The same people every time
You work with Lui, not whoever picks up. Our HR leads keep a small client list on purpose.
Caleb as backup
Caleb Sherrill, our founder, covers when Lui is out and is briefed on your account.
At home in Paychex
We work in Paychex every week, along with ADP, Rippling, Gusto and QuickBooks payroll.
The agreement, in short.
Packages and prices come from the Service Schedule, the exhibit you initial with the agreement. The service levels above go into the agreement too.
- 12-month agreement, with the $2,500 baseline HR audit included at any package.
- The price holds for the first 90 days. After that it moves only if your headcount or states change, with 30 days' notice, down as well as up.
- Nothing to sign on this page. When you say yes, we send the agreement, and the first month is due on signing.
Questions about any of this? Reach either of us.
We're glad to walk your team through it, or to adjust a package to fit what C-Level needs. Say yes by email and the agreement goes out the same day.